A line needs to be drawn under this. For most listeners the magic of Caroline died when it closed in 1968. Its time was over, and that chapter in broadcasting ended. It's very similar that it never works trying to recreate the magic of a classic film with a new version. You could never now recreate Laurel and Hardy, Dad's Army, Thunderbirds or Bagpuss with new versions. Let Caroline rest in peace and enjoy genuine old recordings of her when possible. It's over.