Determining if St Francis actually used these words is a matter of fact.
From what I can glean there is substantial doubt that he did use these exact words.
: Same with quoting St Teresa out of context
: below about her being more frightened of
: those frightened of the devil than of the
: devil itself.
: Reading the quote within the context of
: chapter 25 of The Book of Her Life shows
: that it bears absolutely no relation to your
: statement about dissidents having been
: historically burnt at the stake, despite
: your citation of it in support.
In a sense every 'quote' is taken out of 'context' and it is not a matter of fact if that is done appropriately or not, it is a matter of opinion.
: One thing to be off with the pixies*, Alex,
: another one to misrepresent great saints of
: the Church in order to encourage others
: along.
Speaking of 'fact' and 'opinion', what is Alex encouraging others 'along'?
* It would be quite reasonable to state that you've used that expression 'out of context' or that 'that it bears absolutely no relation to your' assertion about Alex.
Responses
« Back to index | View thread »