Posted by feather-y judge on February 24, 2009, 1:05 am, in reply to "a first time for everything."
69.231.120.X
x. Name reference (0-4) 1: I agree that it's too far reaching, it requires a large amount of assumptions.
x. Harem reference (0-4) 3: to me this does say mountain; A mountain stands above the surrounding land, but one would have to assume that that is the harem ref. and not referring to something else as the other judge stated
x. Rank reference* (0-4) 2: You have to take it literally, in which case it does lead to children, since they're the lowest on the board. But nothing directly relates to children so it can be misleading as many consider children to be high-standing in a herd, and travelers low..
x. History/Achievements reference (0-4) 3
x. Filler** (-2-0)
x. Extras*** (varies/MAX 2.5) .5 for element
TOTAL: 9.5/16
It's a negative for me too, by a small margin. Ultimately parts of it were just too vague.
24
Message Thread:
![]()
« Back to thread