Posted by Judgelet on November 19, 2008, 5:33 pm, in reply to "coolcool"
58.170.129.140
I'm sure this is correct;
Yes, you can't light a match in windy weather, but that would be a Fire I horse where they can only really get a small flame and mess with it. Ethereal is Fire III and well established - regardless, Air is weaker to Fire. I've read in other battles and judgements where they say the weaker element all but disappears and you can't use it against your opponent, and you have to take just a little more damage (and vice versa in the sense the damage you deal doesn't have to be as violent as you intented to the stronger element horse)
I DO want Nat to clarify this just for personal referrence as well, but as I said, from other judgements/fights, that's what I've learnt.
With the timing - it is still a bit relevant that you had to circle her to attack. If you can't be penalised between attacks, again Nat, let me know because I assumed it was all relevant because the timing section was there, and it seemed your horse (by your description) just "circled and attacked" - if you had of had a little more description to say that both hrose's are moving, and you would have had to re-adjust your stride accordlingly or something like that then I personally owuldn't have removed the points. Just seemed to me to say you had a defense then spun around into an attack when Ethereal had just kicked you and disappeared behind you - can you see where I'm coming from?
And Nat, clarification would be greatly appreciated.
Message Thread:
« Back to thread