Posted by THE ELEMENTALS on August 22, 2008, 10:08 am, in reply to "but I flew too high; JUDGES "
Message modified by administrator JudgeJudy August 23, 2008, 1:16 am
CHALLENGER #1 - BARAQEL
Attack One
-----------------
Realism: 4/5 I tend to doubt the feasibility of javelin-pony. By this, I mean sticking his forelegs out and shoving his whole mass behind them.
Power: 5/5 The power is there.
Timing: 5/5
PS, the lightning bolt is pushing the envelope, though I'll let it slide. Here's the exact definition of your Lightning III ability: "Have some of the aspects of the element: i.e. can call a storm, deliver a small shock to others that touch them, dislike or fear of uneven ground/earthquakes/mountains, etc."
Calling a big fat bolt right on Maverick's nose is pushing it. Not going to penalize, but something to keep in mind.
Attack Two
-----------------
Realism: 5/5
Power: 5/5
Timing: 5/5
---------------------------------------------------
CHALLENGER #2 - MAVERICK
Defense One
-----------------
Realism: 5/5 Excellent, and exactly what I would have done.
Damage: 5/5
Timing: 5/5
Defense Two
-----------------
Realism: 5/5
Damage: 4/5 For a leg that's already injured, you don't acknowledge much pain.
Timing: 5/5
Attack One
-----------------
Realism: 5/5 Sure.
Power: 4/5 Don't feel that this is a particularly powerful attack from such a short range; it's likely to injure you too.
Timing: 5/5
Attack Two
-----------------
Realism: 4/5 I'm docking a point here for planting and kicking on an injured foreleg/shoulder.
Power: 5/5
Timing: 5/5
---------------------------------------------------
CHALLENGER #1 - BARAQEL
Defense One
-----------------
Realism: 5/5
Damage: 5/5 You don't take much, but it's not much of a damaging attack.
Timing: 5/5
Defense Two
-----------------
Realism: 5/5
Damage: 3/5
- 1: Getting kicked in the stifle is going to hurt a LOT more than you let on here.
- 1: You could have taken the hit in a much better place.
Timing: 5/5
OVERALL
BARAQEL
-----------------
Total from Above: 57/60
Elemental Score*: +1 for 2nd Element
Bonus Points**:
Penalties***:.
GRAND TOTAL – , 58/60
MAVERICK
-----------------
Total from Above: 57/60
Elemental Score*:
Bonus Points**: +1: Maverick has a very nice, matter-of-fact fighting style.
Penalties***:
GRAND TOTAL – 58/60,
Okay, REALLY?? I did all of this AND the bonus points before I added everything up. WHAT IS THIS.
I'm going to go ahead and call this a tie -- I thought it was very well fought by both of you. I liked the simple battle, it's refreshing to judge every once in awhile. Though you didn't have much weather to work with ;)
Well fought, guys.
Message Thread:
« Back to thread